Well, that clears up who the other mafia is Though, I was wrong - I thought it was Carmine.

You know what, so did I. Can you tell me why you thought this?

Sure can.

First off is just Background Suspicion of her which I feel is a healthy way to treat any other player, not least Carmine There was nothing convincing on her though, just a nagging feeling and being on the various bandwagons. Most of my suspicion was during the night though, after I submitted the choice to investigate miv.

I was trying to work out who I'd suspect if he came up as mafia - looking through the day there was a fair amount of correlation between miv and Carmine. Page 1, after them both deliberating about how they had to be careful, miv quickly followed Carmine's vote on Haug to 2 votes. Page 2 (near the bottom) had them making nigh-identical posts interrogating T. I also figured that with Carmine being on the T bandwagon, that might explain why a Mafia Miv would've gone the extra yard to stay off of it when the day ended.

So I was thinking that if miv came up guilty, Carmine would be his Partner in Crime because of the amount of apparent cooperation. Which goes to show how useful that line of thinking was

Bumblebee I never said you admited your reason where crap, I said I thought
they where (and still do) think they where crap. I therefore thought
"ah ha, a mafia member going for the easy lynch, tonight Ill investigate him!"
then you turned out much to my surprise to be innocent

as for Dasquian Voting for Miv I suggested it because Dasquian is crafty, he knows
how to work a town, but the fact he hasn't removed his vote and Carmine has
added hers makes me believe that Carmine is the second mafia.

tis true though I have handled this terribly, putting the town in the bad spot.
Dasquian is relying on the role name garned from the first post to pass
him through safely, where as I took it for granted and thus made a mess of things.

This all now comes down to you Bumblebee, tonight this is decided. you have 3
options, vote for Miv and allow the Mafia to win, Vote for Dasquian or Carmine and aid the Town.
or vote for a no lynch, remember though that a no lynch (if it is completed)
will result in either, you, me or Miv dying tonight and this ending in a Tie.

oh and if you want to see which game I played in, follow Dasquians link and
look for the game with ABANDONED
(lack of info, particpation and moderators) next to its name, I didnt post a
link because it would have been redundant.

and yes, if you get this wrong i'll never let you forget it. :wink:

Alluric

that dosent make sense, there will be two townies and two mafia, a tie situation.

Alluric

now who's playing dumb, did you forget about your own night kill.
if we go no lynch today, The mafia still kill a townie tonight
leaving us with two townies and two mafia. a tie situation as far as I understand it.
and just so you know, id never advocate a no lynch twice in a row.

and Yes, id always prefer a tie over a mafia win because atleast part of the town survives, where as Dasquian appears to want a mafia win much more then a tie.

Bumblebee the choice is yours, Id prefer a town win all the same so choose Dasquian or Carmine.

Alluric

Never trust Dasquian!

good luck Bumblebee

Alluric

Actually I didn't, in the card (real world) game (atleast at my school where I learnt it)
if it came down to an even number of Mafia to Townies the game ends as a tie.

but then again, I wouldnt trust you as your the second mafia member.

Alluric

except that if bumblebee votes for miv today I die tonight and its all over tommorow.

I cant handle the suspense, make the vote now

Alluric

*breathes a sigh of relief*

You've made the right decision

Ordering games, last post.