Want to take part in these discussions? If you have an account, sign in now.
If you don't have an account, apply for one now.
Noise - Mafia discussion: Mafia But More So - Discussion Thread
Bottom of PageThat's a hilarious read-through of the night choices!
Only potentially 6 deaths in the one night? Surely if everyone had tried to use their killing power at once we could've done better than that?
For what it's worth, Carmine, I didn't attempt to kill on Night One because since I had a nice safe claim as a Mason, I didn't want any extra deaths that might make people think "Oh, guess we have a serial killer as well as a Mafia then". Once HC claimed I felt safe to up the body count. And of course, I didn't realise that the Mafia could each kill every night. Ye gods. I'm amazed we only had one death a night.
I'm mildly suprised at how often people tried to kill you, Tick.
And yeah, I wasn't counting my chickens on the last day at all. Das' has it right, I was quite aware that even if we'd managed to deadline-lynch Mono or Lacero, then there was a damn good chance that tick would wake up alone the next day. I wouldn't have minded too much if tick had won tho'. It was kinda weird. Felt like I was on two teams at once really.Kudos to Jozline + Spooky for Day One by the way. Spooky's early unprovoked Cop claim which made me so suspicious of her certainly worked for keeping her safe into the endgame, and I reckon that the fact that Jozline was about the only one who agreed about that point made SPooky look even better once Joz' got lynched.
Big tip of the Hat to Mono too, who managed to stay nicely under the radar for so long!
I'm curious about what sort of extra infomation about the number of killing groups Hi Colonic had. Well, claimed he had.
1000 miles from the chimera I chase...- CommentAuthorHi Colonic
- CommentTimeSep 30th 2007
I went of the two girls on night one because they are often easiest to provoke into a response, or let something slip. And indeed I was right. Course, I pissed them off because anyone who could kill me did, the next night. What I knew about killing groups was that I had the power to kill, and hadn't, so there was at least one more group (me!)
Nice game, although I didn't follow much after my death, I confess.
Sorry I ballsed up my results when claiming. I was pretty fluish too. But that rocked. And I think I learned a lot from it.
Thanks Carmine - and thanks everyone!
Normal is an illusionJames, why on earth would you say
Night One - HC, SPOOKYBETH
Night Two - Tick and LPWhen carmine thinks on night 1:
Vig/Mad Cop (James) - Investigate Tick/Investigate Spookybeth - Results: Guilty/Guilty
and night 2
Vig/Mad Cop (James) - Investigate Hi Colonic/Investigate Daegul - Results: Guilty/Guilty
And then say you base most of your day 1 play on a result on HC which you never had??
I'm sorry I went after you so much, but a lot of it was baed on your bad claim, changing of night choices, and no correlation between said choices and your actual actions.
Generally, the mafia are the ones lying in this game. If you slip up, you look vey guilty. If it is an innocent slip-up you best have a way of explaining it.
Can't really ask for a sig and then not have one now, can i?The best way I have of explaining it is that I fucked up. I played this game really badly due to a lot of pressure going on in real life. If that should happen when/if I play again, I shall request a replacement.
Normal is an illusion