Want to take part in these discussions? If you have an account, sign in now.
If you don't have an account, apply for one now.
Noise - Mafia games: [Closed] Mini 3: Storybook Mafia - Game over, town wins!
Bottom of PageI am Arnold Fletcher, a stout little boy who enjoys eating practically everything that comes in my way. I can usually be found trying to arrange matters to be exactly so that food does, indeed, go my way.
So.. one of you three. Haug could be a blocker mafia, serentiy claimed last so could've made up the doc role (mafia cop seems impossible), and HC could have cruised through while we were all distracted by Daegul.
I think a reread is in order.
- CommentAuthorHi Colonic
- CommentTimeJun 12th 2006
While you're reading through, make sure you spot the bit where I killed the Mafia guy. Not only did I kill him, but I proposed the bad wagon to start with. Given the choice of the silent Sad Genius and the silent Evis/you, we went for SG. Perhaps we should have got both.
Is the only thing clearing you currently the fact that you may have been absent one night?
- CommentAuthorHi Colonic
- CommentTimeJun 12th 2006
Oh, and I may experience radio silence for 48 hours. I am away at an empty house, and I'm not sure if the phone works. I could use my Palm, but it's like peeling your eyeballs.
Had a couple of crap days, and a 50 mile bike ride yesterday that annihilated me. I'm re-reading now to see what I can find.
I should post a little later.
- CommentAuthorHi Colonic
- CommentTimeJun 18th 2006
so, has no-one got anything to say?
4/5 days with no comment? Haug/Serentiy can you vouch for another? If so, who's evil, if not why not. I'm assuming you can and that only leaves one possibility.
So, help me out..
Well I don't know.
I assume that Serenity is innocent, but there really is no proof.
I claimed I blocked him on a certain night and then he said he was blocked. He also suggested he baked pies (doesn't really sound like a doctor role, but hey, I'm a lumberjack).
Serenity also said that he found out that HC was innocent because he was 'sleeping' one night. Sorta fits in with his role, but then again he could just be saying that to make an 'alliance' between himself and HC (so HC sees him as innocent). This means HC is evil and Serenity is innocent or HC is innocent and Serenity is evil.
It would seem unlikely that the other guy, Lacero, is evil because of the whole Eviscerator situation, but I don't know.
I've said everything else before, and am waiting for someone else to do a re-read and see if there is anything I have missed that might incriminate someone. We have all the information, just need to find flaws.
ok, I've done a re-read. I suck at them and I found nothing useful, but I've been thinking about the set up we have here.
First thing is Haug started all this mess with his crazy plan so I want to kill him for it. I don't think this is a great idea though, Serentiy is claiming to be blocked so the only way Haug can be evil is if he's a mafia blocker. I'm told this isn't unheard of but it's a lot to risk a game on.
Second thing is, if we have a townie blocker we can definately win if the evil one is Hi Colonic or Serenity. We lynch HC, then Haug blocks serenity, either HC is evil and we've already won or serenity is and me and Haug lynch them tomorrow.
While I think the set up we seem to be playing with (1 blocker, 1 doc, 1 cop vs. 2 mafia and 1 sk) is a bit odd I can't find anyway Haug can be guilty without him actually having the power to block.
That's a great idea!
Of course, if we have the whole Evi idea back to front, you could come in and kill us!
But yeah, why not.
Vote Hi Colonic
Crap, I completely forgot about this game.
I did a re-read and didn't find anything, but I'm sort of in agreement with Lacero. Sort of.
I'm doctor and Haug is blocker, so I believe pretty firmly in the innocence of those two people. It basically comes down to HC vs. Lacero. If we lynch HC today, then Lacero needs the block at night, if there is a night.
It's a mafia win if Lacero is mafia, as Haug will be blocking me and Lacero will kill one of us for the win.
I'm gonna ghost vote HC until we work out what Haug will do, as I don't want Lacero to be able to cast the last vote without a firm decision.
Well here is what we have:
*We vote off HC because he does not have anything supporting his claim.So, this leaves us with one night to get it right.
Lacero is assumed innocent because of Evi being absent when there was a kill (if I remember correctly no mafia member was killed from that point, so whoever did the killing on that night is still alive). Of course, we do not know under what circumstances Evi left. He may have been replaced because he was AFK, or because he could no longer play. If it is the second, then that means he could have killed. If it is the first, that means Lacero is innocent. Sadly, there is no real way to find this out other than what Lacero says.
The second is Serenity. He has claimed doctor, but there is no real way to prove this (seeing as he said that he was blocked after I said I blocked him). However, I believe that this game would have at least one doctor (the stats add up to it). Also, I do not think anyone has said that someone protected them, so again there is no way to clarify the role.
And then there is Haugy. Haugy is innocent because he is (yeah).
If I wasn't innocent why would I have not killed someone last night? I could've killed the blocker and made this a 2v1 with much more chance of me winning. No one would know who Haug blocked as he wouldn't be around to tell us, combined with Serenity's unverifiable doctor claim and HC's under the radar townie I should've won easily, if I were mafia.
I think Evi didn't come back because he had what he saw as a boring townie role, it happens. I agree with Haug theres no proof at all that Serenity is a doctor, serenity's story backs up Haug (claiming to be blocked) but Haug's doesn't back up serenity.
I agree it's likely theres a doctor but I know it's not me and Haug must be a blocker otherwise serenity is lying. So HC and serenity are the ones that have to die and be blocked from my point of view.
Hope HC gets back soonish, I think this game must've lasted 6 months total by now it's be good to get it finished
Since HC hasn't come back and disputed anything, I'm going to vote HC.
There's not even an argument unless he claims doctor also, at which point I'll be certain. I'm still of the opinion that it's better to block Lacero than me though, just in case his strategy was to hold his kill to get us to lynch HC today, providing him with a win if I'm blocked. Hopefully the block won't be needed at all.
HC, you've got until Lacero votes to say something in your defense.
On the off chance he's not evil I'll give him time to tell me "Noooo, you've just let XXX win!". Also as who to block is entirely up to Haug theres no point waiting around for an agreement on that, we've both said our piece it's up to him.
Lets just hope he's not a mafia blocker
- CommentAuthorHi Colonic
- CommentTimeJun 28th 2006
Sorry. BT cut me off.
I'm here!
Say something quick then...
I'm innocent, and I think Lacero is the guilty person.
I need to check back, but I'm sure Serenity mentioned a night when I was blocked and there was a kill, but let's wait for a link on that one (I'll dig back).
More pointedly, I killed Sad Genius. In a game with such low numbers, I chose to kill SG and not push for Evis. The only thing suggesting Lacero is the innocent one is his supposed absence on a night when there was no kill. Is there actually any evidence for that?
vote Lacero
well I'm innocent and so I might as well push in case HC is guilty. Hope you block the right person Haug. (Thats serenity btw, him claiming last would be enough reason to believe that if I were in your place).
Vote Hi Colonic
- CommentAuthorHi Colonic
- CommentTimeJun 28th 2006
Bah, we need a mod replaced!
Anyone taking bets on this game lasting until August?
With those votes, that's a Lynch of HC!
-------------------------------------
"Storytime! Storytime!", Bob chirps. "I've a feeling I know who the town is going to off today!"
Dad peers at Bob with all his excitement regarding lynching people, and secretly hopes he'll never get in a position of significant power. "Right, let's open the book and read on, shall we?"
Dad opens the book, which reads:"The town of Bathrobia were decided, it could be none other than that Hi Colonic responsible for the killings. And if it wasn't, they'd kill somebody else... "We'll get it right eventually, s'all in the numbers eh?", a random villager comments."
The right page shows said villager attempting to look very wise, with his finger in the air and hand on the chest.
"Kill everybody till things are right, eh?", Bob muses whilst Dad just looks... horrified. He decides to just keep reading, and burn this book first chance he gets.
He turns the page.
The left page reads:"Hi Colonic was dragged out of his home and dragged to the Big Oak Tree, where he gets a rope tied around his neck and people inspect him carefully, just in case he's wearing glasses, an apron or anything else that would surely imply him being a townie.
The right page shows Hi Colonic, with hands tied, standing on a bucket and a noose around his neck. Various townies are inspecting him, but there's not really a chance to mistake his green skin. He's evil alright!
"DIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!", Bob screams.
"Alright, that's enough. It's going to be the psychiatrist for you, son!"
Dad chucks the book away into a corner of the room, where it briefly shows a picture of the town (or what's left of it) celebrating the death of the last evil goblin.
Then a gust of wind closes the book shut, where the letters and pictures rearrange themselves to form a new story, for a new slightly disturbing son.
TOWN WINS!